List China Events Chinese Culture China Watch Chinese Music Land of China Chinese Festival Chinese History Chinese Architecture Chinese Medicine People in China What Chinese Say Martial Arts China Tales World Watch World Beyond Amusing & Musing


Home >> World Watch

Analysts Question Korea Torpedo Incident (2)

29 May 2010
 

The Following are some comments from viewers:

steve_k2

I thought this sounded fishy from the start. It's another trumped up Golf of Tonkin incident. Considering that the north has nukes, this is crazy.

这事看来确实有猫腻,和海湾战争时的技俩有得一拼。可这回是北朝啊,人家有核武,这不是疯了吗.

ccarrick1:

I would like to see our intrepid reporter check out the 6 May Reuters story in which a Yonhap story, citing an unidentified senior South Korean source, discusses a topic I have seen nowhere else:

"The metallic debris and chemical residue appear to be consistent with a type of torpedo made in Germany, indicating the North may have been trying to disguise its involvement by avoiding arms made by allies China and Russia, Yonhap quoted the official as saying."

Why did someone high up in the South Korean government tell the South Korean media that the torpedo was identified as of German make? The North Koreans have none in their inventory--though they could have acquired some, no doubt. But could they be fired from a NK submarine? Interestingly, the entire South Korean submarine component is composed of German-made submarines, Type 214s and Type 209s. Wonder if the South Koreans could have somehow inadvertently hit their own ship and then tried to cover it up.

请注意以下这段发布于五月六号的路透社的报道。其中提到对一位未提名姓的南朝鲜有来头人物的访谈。该人物说:

“鱼雷的金属碎片和化学残迹与德国制鱼雷上的一致,这似乎说明北朝想掩盖鱼雷的真正产地,或者是中国,或者是俄国。"

你说你脑残的南朝鲜政府干嘛要告诉南朝鲜媒体那枚鱼雷是德国造的呢?全世界的人民都知道北朝鲜没有德国货 – 当然他们从哪儿弄到一两枚那也是有可能的,但它们的非德国配制的潜艇能发射德国鱼雷吗?另一方面,全世界的人民都知道,南朝鲜的潜艇整个都是德国装置,214系列,209系列。鬼知道南朝鲜舰队是不是因为内讧而自相残杀,然后嫁祸于人逃避罪责

Torpedo

Can you say....Gulf of Tonkin.

And even if the facts are as stated, I wonder if the americans would have responded any differently if some unfriendly naval power was conducting naval exercises within disputed american territorial waters.

当初海湾战争的翻版啊。

退一万步,即使鱼雷真是北朝鲜发射的,那又怎么样?要是哪个不友好国家派战舰到有争议的美国附近海域耀武扬威,你看美国发不发鱼雷。当然发。

Prev: South Korea Calim Questioned (1)
Next: Did U.S. Mine Sink SKorean Ship? (1)

 
 
RELATED:

Home List About This Website Contact Us

Copyright © 2008 - 2017